Capital Rationing
Capital rationing is when a company cannot fund every positive-NPV project it has. Hard vs. soft rationing, and how to rank projects by profitability index.
Contents
Capital rationing is the situation in which a company has more attractive investment opportunities than it has capital to fund, so it must choose among projects that would each add value. The limit can be imposed by lenders and markets or set by management. The aim is to pick the combination of projects that creates the most value within the budget.
Capital rationing is part of capital budgeting. Without a funding constraint, a company would accept every project with a positive net present value (NPV). With one, it has to rank them.
Types of capital rationing
Hard capital rationing
Hard rationing comes from outside the company. It cannot raise more debt or equity, or can do so only on prohibitive terms, because of weak credit, tight credit markets, debt covenants or, for a young company, limited access to investors.
Soft capital rationing
Soft rationing is self-imposed. Management caps the investment budget or gives each division a fixed allocation, often to avoid diluting shareholders, protect a credit rating, keep leverage within targets, or limit growth to what the organization can execute well. Some companies also ration capital deliberately to offset optimistic forecasts in project proposals.
How to rank projects under capital rationing
When projects compete for a fixed budget, ranking by NPV favors sizable projects even if they produce less value per dollar invested. The standard tool is the profitability index (PI):
Profitability index = Present value of future cash flows ÷ Initial investment
The numerator is the present value of the cash a project is expected to generate, discounted at the company's weighted average cost of capital (WACC) or a risk-adjusted rate. A PI above 1.0 means a positive NPV. Under a single-period budget limit, rank projects from highest to lowest PI and fund them in order until the money runs out. Because projects typically cannot be partly funded, then check whether a different combination uses the budget better.
Capital rationing example
A company has a $500,000 capital budget and five independent proposals:
- Project A: cost $300,000, NPV $55,000, PI 1.18
- Project B: cost $200,000, NPV $50,000, PI 1.25
- Project C: cost $150,000, NPV $33,000, PI 1.22
- Project D: cost $100,000, NPV $28,000, PI 1.28
- Project E: cost $250,000, NPV $40,000, PI 1.16
All five have positive NPVs, but together they would cost $1 million. Ranking by NPV selects A and B, which use the full $500,000 for a combined NPV of $105,000. Ranking by PI picks D, B and C, which cost $450,000 and produce a combined NPV of $111,000, the best result of any combination that fits the budget. The remaining $50,000 is too little for any other project, so it can be held or returned to investors.
Capital rationing vs. capital budgeting
Capital budgeting is the entire process of evaluating and approving long-term investments. Capital rationing is a constraint within it. In theory, a company with access to fairly priced capital should fund every positive-NPV project, so rationing means leaving some value unrealized in exchange for lower risk, financial flexibility or tighter control.
Limitations of profitability index ranking
- Indivisible projects. PI ranking can leave part of the budget unused, and a combination that includes a lower-ranked project may produce more total NPV. Always review the alternatives that fit.
- Multi-year constraints. If capital is limited in several future years, not just today, simple ranking breaks down, and companies use linear or integer programming to find the best mix.
- Dependent projects. Mutually exclusive projects, or projects that only work together, have to be assessed as packages.
- Strategic value. Some projects with lower PIs, such as regulatory upgrades or platforms for future growth, may still be required.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between hard and soft capital rationing?
Hard rationing is imposed from outside, when a company cannot raise capital on acceptable terms. Soft rationing is imposed internally by management through budget caps or divisional limits.
Why use the profitability index instead of NPV under capital rationing?
The profitability index measures value created per dollar invested, which is what matters when dollars are scarce. NPV ranking tends to favor sizable projects that consume the budget, as the example shows.
Is capital rationing good or bad?
It is a trade-off. Soft rationing can impose discipline and protect the balance sheet, but turning down positive-NPV projects means giving up value that shareholders would otherwise receive.
Can IRR be used to rank projects under capital rationing?
It can screen projects, but ranking by internal rate of return (IRR) can produce a different order from the profitability index and does not reliably maximize total NPV within the budget. PI ranking is the usual approach.