Jensen's Alpha
Jensen's alpha measures how far a portfolio's return beat or missed what CAPM predicts for its beta. Formula, worked example, and alpha vs. Sharpe and Treynor.
Contents
Jensen's alpha is a measure of risk-adjusted investment performance: the return a portfolio earned above or below what the capital asset pricing model (CAPM) predicts for the amount of market risk it took. A positive alpha means the manager outperformed after accounting for beta; a negative alpha means the portfolio fell short. Economist Michael Jensen introduced it in 1968 to assess mutual fund managers.
It is also called Jensen's measure, Jensen's performance index or ex post alpha. Fund analysts, pension consultants and investment committees use it to judge whether a manager's returns reflect skill or merely exposure to the market.
Jensen's alpha formula
α = Rp − [Rf + βp × (Rm − Rf)]
- Rp is the portfolio's actual return over the period.
- Rf is the risk-free rate over the same period, such as the Treasury bill yield.
- βp is the portfolio's beta, its sensitivity to market movements.
- Rm is the return on the market benchmark, such as the S&P 500.
The bracketed term is the CAPM expected return, the same formula used to estimate a required rate of return. Alpha is whatever the portfolio earned beyond that.
How to calculate Jensen's alpha
- Measure the portfolio's return and the benchmark's return over the same period, with the portfolio's return net of fees.
- Find the risk-free rate for that period.
- Estimate the portfolio's beta, typically by regressing its excess returns (Rp − Rf) on the market's excess returns (Rm − Rf). In that regression, beta is the slope and Jensen's alpha is the intercept.
- Calculate the CAPM expected return: Rf + βp × (Rm − Rf).
- Subtract the expected return from the actual return.
Jensen's alpha example
Over a year, Fund A returned 12% and Fund B returned 13%. The risk-free rate was 3% and the market returned 9%, so the market risk premium was 6%. Fund A has a beta of 1.2 and Fund B a beta of 1.6.
- Fund A expected return: 3% + 1.2 × 6% = 10.2%. Alpha = 12% − 10.2% = +1.8%.
- Fund B expected return: 3% + 1.6 × 6% = 12.6%. Alpha = 13% − 12.6% = +0.4%.
Fund B had the higher raw return, but it took far more market risk to get it. After adjusting for beta, Fund A's Jensen's alpha is 1.4 percentage points higher, so on this measure it added more value through security selection or timing.
How to interpret Jensen's alpha
- Positive alpha: the portfolio beat the return its beta would justify, which may suggest skill.
- Zero alpha: the portfolio earned exactly what its market risk predicted, as an index fund with a matching beta would be expected to before costs.
- Negative alpha: the portfolio underperformed on a risk-adjusted basis.
Fees reduce alpha directly, so a manager has to beat the CAPM return by more than the fund's costs to deliver positive alpha to investors. A single year's alpha can also be luck. Analysts look at alpha over several years and test whether it is statistically different from zero before crediting a manager with skill.
Jensen's alpha vs. Sharpe ratio and Treynor ratio
- Jensen's alpha is the excess return, in percentage points, over what CAPM predicts for the portfolio's beta.
- Treynor ratio = (Rp − Rf) ÷ βp, the excess return per unit of market risk. Fund A scores 7.5 and Fund B 6.25, the same ranking as alpha.
- Sharpe ratio = (Rp − Rf) ÷ σp, where σp is the standard deviation of the portfolio's returns. It adjusts for total volatility, not just market risk.
Alpha and the Treynor ratio assume the portfolio is one diversified part of a larger holding, so only market risk matters. For an investor's whole portfolio, or a concentrated fund, the Sharpe ratio is usually the better guide.
Limitations of Jensen's alpha
- It depends on CAPM. If CAPM misprices certain kinds of stocks, such as small or value companies, alpha can reflect that investment style rather than skill. Multi-factor models, such as the Fama-French models, measure alpha against several risk factors instead.
- The benchmark matters. Measuring a small-cap fund against a large-cap index can create false alpha.
- Beta changes. A portfolio's beta can shift over time, especially with active trading or the use of leverage.
- It ignores other risks. Alpha says nothing about drawdowns or downside measures such as value at risk.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good Jensen's alpha?
Any alpha above zero means the portfolio beat its CAPM expected return. A good alpha is one that remains positive after fees and persists over several years.
Can Jensen's alpha be negative?
Yes. A negative alpha means the portfolio earned less than CAPM predicts for its beta, so investors would have done better holding a mix of the market index and risk-free assets with the same beta.
What is the difference between alpha and beta?
Beta measures how much a portfolio moves with the market. Alpha measures the return it earned beyond what that market exposure explains.
Is Jensen's alpha the same as alpha?
Jensen's alpha is the most common formal definition. In everyday use, "alpha" often simply means return above a benchmark without adjusting for beta, so check which one a fund is reporting.