Modified Cash Basis Accounting
Modified cash basis accounting blends cash and accrual methods: cash basis for most items, but fixed assets and debt go on the books. With an example.
Contents
Modified cash basis accounting is a hybrid method that records most revenue and expenses when cash is received or paid, but treats a few long-lived items the way accrual accounting does. Fixed assets are capitalized and depreciated, and long-term debt is recorded as a liability, instead of running every purchase and loan through income as cash moves. It is a special-purpose framework, not GAAP.
Small businesses, nonprofits, homeowners associations and some local governments use it because it is easier than full accrual accounting but gives a fairer picture than pure cash basis when the organization buys equipment or borrows.
How modified cash basis accounting works
The starting point is the cash basis: sales are income when the customer pays, and bills are expenses when they are paid. There are no accounts receivable for unpaid customer invoices and no accounts payable for unpaid supplier bills. The organization then makes a limited set of modifications for items that would seriously distort the results if left on a cash basis.
Common modifications include:
- Fixed assets: equipment, vehicles and buildings are recorded as a fixed asset and depreciated over their useful lives, rather than expensed when paid for.
- Long-term debt: loans are recorded as long-term liabilities; principal repayments reduce the liability and only interest is an expense.
- Payroll withholdings: taxes withheld from employees but not yet remitted are shown as a liability.
- Inventory or prepaid expenses: sometimes capitalized and expensed as used, where the amounts are significant.
- Income taxes: sometimes accrued.
Auditing standards require each modification to have substantial support, meaning it follows a recognized accounting treatment rather than a preference, and to be applied consistently. A company cannot pick and choose accruals each year to smooth its results.
Modified cash basis example
A small services company has the following year:
- Cash received from customers: $420,000, of which $35,000 was for work done the prior year.
- Invoices for this year's work still unpaid at year-end: $50,000.
- Operating expenses paid in cash: $300,000, all for this year. Bills received but unpaid at year-end: $18,000.
- Equipment purchased for $60,000 cash in January, with a five-year life and no salvage value.
Net income under each method:
- Cash basis: $420,000 − $300,000 − $60,000 equipment = $60,000.
- Modified cash basis: $420,000 − $300,000 − $12,000 depreciation ($60,000 ÷ 5) = $108,000. The equipment appears as an asset with a net book value of $48,000.
- Accrual basis: revenue of $435,000 ($420,000 − $35,000 + $50,000), less expenses of $318,000 ($300,000 + $18,000) and $12,000 of depreciation = $105,000.
Pure cash basis charges the entire equipment purchase to one year, so profit looks $48,000 lower than under the modified method. The modified cash result lands much closer to the accrual figure, but it still ignores the $50,000 owed by customers and the $18,000 owed to suppliers.
Modified cash vs. cash vs. accrual basis
- Cash basis records everything when cash moves. It is the simplest, but a big purchase or loan can swing results sharply.
- Modified cash basis keeps the cash basis for day-to-day revenue and expenses but adds a balance sheet with fixed assets, depreciation and debt.
- Accrual basis records revenue when earned and expenses when incurred, with receivables, payables, accruals and deferrals. It is required for GAAP and IFRS statements.
Modified cash basis vs. modified accrual basis
The names are alike, but the methods are not. The modified accrual basis is used by US state and local governments for their governmental funds under GASB standards. It recognizes revenue when it is measurable and available to pay current-period obligations, and expenditures generally when the liability is incurred. The modified cash basis is a cash method with a few accrual adjustments.
Advantages and limitations
Advantages: it is cheaper and easier to maintain than accrual accounting, needs no month-end accruals for every bill, and still spreads the cost of major assets over the years that use them. Cash results remain easy to compare with the bank balance.
Limitations:
- It is not GAAP, so lenders, investors or grantors who require GAAP statements will not accept it, and an auditor's report on it will say it was prepared on a special-purpose framework.
- It hides what customers owe and what the organization owes, so profit can be overstated or understated around year-end.
- Results are tougher to compare with companies that use accrual accounting.
- Moving to accrual later, for a loan, an investor or an acquisition, means rebuilding opening balances.
Statements prepared this way are typically titled to show the basis, for example a statement of revenues and expenses (modified cash basis) rather than an income statement, and the notes describe each modification.
Frequently asked questions
Is modified cash basis accounting GAAP?
No. It is a special-purpose framework, previously called an other comprehensive basis of accounting (OCBOA). Statements prepared on it can be audited or reviewed, but the report states the basis used.
Who uses the modified cash basis?
Mainly small businesses, nonprofits, homeowners associations, churches and some small local governments whose users accept non-GAAP statements. It suits organizations with few receivables and payables but significant equipment or loans.
Is modified cash basis the same as tax basis accounting?
No. The income tax basis is a separate special-purpose framework that follows the methods used on the tax return. A business may use a cash method for tax and modified cash for its statements, but the two are not interchangeable.
Are accounts receivable recorded under modified cash basis?
Usually not. Revenue is recorded when the customer pays, so unpaid invoices remain off the books unless the organization adopts a supported modification for them.