Tax Shield

A tax shield is the tax saved by a deductible expense such as interest or depreciation, equal to the deduction times the tax rate. Formula, examples and FAQs.

4 min readGlossary
Contents
  1. Tax shield formula
  2. Interest tax shield example
  3. Depreciation tax shield example
  4. Limits on tax shields
  5. Tax shield vs. tax credit
  6. Frequently asked questions

A tax shield is the reduction in income tax a company receives from an expense that tax law allows it to deduct. Because the deduction lowers taxable income, the tax saved equals the deductible amount multiplied by the tax rate. The two most cited are the interest tax shield, which makes debt financing cheaper, and the depreciation tax shield, which lowers the after-tax cost of buying assets.

Tax shield formula

Tax shield = Deductible expense × Tax rate

  • Deductible expense is any cost that reduces taxable income, most frequently interest, depreciation and amortization.
  • Tax rate is the marginal rate that would have applied to the income the deduction offsets. For a US company that is the 21% federal corporate rate plus any state income tax, net of the federal deduction for state tax.

So an interest tax shield is interest expense × tax rate, and a depreciation tax shield is tax depreciation × tax rate. The shield is only worth anything if the company has taxable income to offset, either this year or, through loss carryforwards, in later years.

Interest tax shield example

Two companies each earn EBIT of $1,000,000 and pay federal tax at 21%. Company A has no debt. Company B has borrowed $2,500,000 at 8%, so it pays $200,000 of interest.

  • Company A: taxable income $1,000,000, tax $210,000, net income $790,000
  • Company B: taxable income $800,000, tax $168,000, net income $632,000

Company B pays $42,000 less tax, precisely $200,000 × 21%, so its interest tax shield is $42,000. Its net income is $158,000 lower, not $200,000 lower, and the total paid out to its lenders and shareholders is $832,000 ($632,000 + $200,000), compared with $790,000 for Company A. The additional $42,000 is money that would otherwise have gone to the government.

The same effect gives the after-tax cost of debt used in the weighted average cost of capital: 8% × (1 − 21%) = 6.32%. If the debt is treated as permanent, the present value of the shield is the tax rate times the debt, 21% × $2,500,000 = $525,000, the same as $42,000 ÷ 8%. This is the Modigliani-Miller result with corporate taxes, and part of the case for using some debt in a company's capital structure.

Depreciation tax shield example

A company purchases a $1,000,000 machine and depreciates it for tax over five years. Straight-line depreciation of $200,000 a year cuts tax by $42,000 a year, $210,000 over the asset's life. Depreciation is a non-cash expense, so the shield is a real cash saving, which is why it is added back in cash flow forecasts and discounted cash flow models.

Accelerated depreciation does not change the total. Under double-declining balance, switching to straight-line in year four, the deductions are $400,000, $240,000, $144,000, $108,000 and $108,000, still $1,000,000 in total and still a $210,000 shield, but more of it comes early. Discounted at 8%, the present value of the shield rises from about $167,700 under straight-line to about $177,100. Tax systems set their own schedules, such as MACRS in the US and capital cost allowance in Canada, so tax depreciation often differs from the book depreciation in the financial statements.

Limits on tax shields

  • Taxable income is needed: a loss-making company gets no immediate benefit. Losses carried forward preserve some value, but a postponed saving is worth less.
  • Interest limits: many countries, including the US and Canada, cap the net interest expense a company can deduct in a year, typically as a share of a tax measure of earnings. Disallowed interest can often be carried forward.
  • Financial distress: each extra dollar of debt adds shield value but also raises the risk and cost of financial distress, which is why more leverage is not always better.
  • Rate changes: a lower tax rate reduces the value of every future deduction.

Tax shield vs. tax credit

A tax shield comes from a deduction, so its value depends on the rate: a $100,000 deduction at 21% saves $21,000. A tax credit reduces the tax bill directly, so a $100,000 credit saves $100,000 regardless of the rate.

Frequently asked questions

How do you calculate an interest tax shield?

Multiply the deductible interest expense by the company's marginal tax rate. $200,000 of interest at 21% gives a $42,000 tax shield.

Is depreciation a tax shield?

Yes. Tax depreciation is a deductible non-cash expense, so it reduces taxes paid by the depreciation amount times the tax rate without any cash going out for the expense itself.

Why are dividends not a tax shield?

Dividends are paid out of after-tax profit and are not deductible for the company paying them, so they do not reduce its taxable income. That difference is one reason debt is typically a cheaper source of capital than equity.

What tax rate should be used for a tax shield?

Use the marginal rate, the rate that applies to the income being offset, rather than the effective rate. For a US company that is the combined federal and state rate, which is above 21% wherever a state income tax applies.

Let’s make AP
work for you.