Zero-Based Budgeting

Zero-based budgeting (ZBB) builds each budget from zero, so every expense must be justified for the new period. See how it works, an example, pros and cons.

4 min readGlossary
Contents
  1. How zero-based budgeting works
  2. Zero-based budgeting example
  3. Zero-based budgeting vs. incremental budgeting
  4. Advantages of zero-based budgeting
  5. Disadvantages of zero-based budgeting
  6. How companies apply ZBB in practice
  7. Frequently asked questions

Zero-based budgeting (ZBB) is a budgeting method in which every expense must be justified from scratch each budget cycle, instead of starting from last year's budget and adjusting it. Managers explain what each activity accomplishes, what it costs and what would happen without it, and money goes to the activities that earn their place. The aim is to remove low-value spending that incremental budgets carry forward year after year.

Peter Pyhrr developed the method while working at Texas Instruments and described it in Harvard Business Review in 1970. Jimmy Carter adopted it as governor of Georgia in the early 1970s and required it of federal agencies as president in 1977. Companies today apply it mainly to overhead and other discretionary costs.

How zero-based budgeting works

  1. Define decision units. Break the organization into the activities, cost centers or programs that will be budgeted separately.
  2. Build decision packages. For each unit, describe the activity, its cost, its benefits and the consequences of not funding it. Packages frequently show several levels of effort, such as a minimum level and the current level.
  3. Rank the packages. Managers, and then leadership, rank all packages by the value they deliver for their cost.
  4. Fund down the ranking. Packages are approved in order until the available budget runs out. Anything below the cut-off is reduced or removed.
  5. Monitor and repeat. Track actual spending against the approved packages during the year, and rebuild from zero in the next cycle.

Zero-based budgeting example

A marketing department spent $1.2 million last year. Under incremental budgeting, it might just ask for 5% more, or $1.26 million. Under zero-based budgeting, it starts at zero and submits five decision packages totaling $1.25 million, ranked by the qualified sales leads each one produces:

  1. Core website, CRM and analytics: $300,000
  2. Paid search, the largest source of qualified leads: $350,000
  3. Two industry trade shows: $250,000
  4. Event sponsorships: $220,000
  5. Print advertising and directory listings: $130,000

Leadership funds the first three packages, for an approved budget of $900,000. That is $300,000 (25%) less than last year's spending and $360,000 (about 29%) below the incremental request. Sponsorships and print will have to make a better case to be funded in the next cycle.

Zero-based budgeting vs. incremental budgeting

Incremental budgeting, the way most operating budgets are built, takes the prior year's budget or actual spending as the base and adds or subtracts a percentage for inflation, growth or savings targets. It is quick and stable, but it assumes the existing base is justified, so inefficient spending tends to continue. Zero-based budgeting questions the base itself. It produces a more deliberate budget but takes far more time, data and management attention.

ZBB is also different from top-down budgeting. Decision packages are typically built bottom-up by the managers who run each activity, though leadership often sets an overall savings target first.

Advantages of zero-based budgeting

  • Removes legacy spending: costs that no longer serve a purpose, such as unused software licenses or recurring contracts nobody reviews, come to light.
  • Links spending to priorities: money moves toward the activities that deliver the most rather than staying where it was last year.
  • Improves cost knowledge: managers have to understand what drives their costs and what each activity produces.
  • Builds accountability: each approved package states what the spending should accomplish, which makes later review easier.

Disadvantages of zero-based budgeting

  • Time and effort: justifying every line each cycle takes much longer than an incremental budget and requires detailed cost data.
  • Short-term bias: spending with long-term or hard-to-measure benefits, such as brand building, training or research, is easy to cut and hard to defend.
  • Gaming: managers may exaggerate the case for their packages, or rank essential items low to protect discretionary ones.
  • Poor fit for committed costs: leases, debt service and regulatory costs cannot be rebuilt from zero each year.

How companies apply ZBB in practice

Because a full rebuild every year is expensive, many organizations limit ZBB to discretionary overhead costs and SG&A, such as travel, marketing, consulting and software, or rotate it so that each department goes through a zero-based review every few years. Others apply it by cost category, setting spending rules (for example, which class of travel is permitted) and checking compliance in monthly variance reporting.

Savings from a zero-based review tend to hold only when spending is compared against the approved packages during the year. Without that control, costs drift back toward the old base.

Frequently asked questions

What is zero-based budgeting in simple terms?

Zero-based budgeting means building each new budget from nothing rather than from last year's numbers. Every expense has to be justified for the coming period before it is funded.

Who created zero-based budgeting?

Peter Pyhrr developed zero-based budgeting at Texas Instruments and published it in Harvard Business Review in 1970. Jimmy Carter's use of it in Georgia and in the federal government made it widely known.

What is the difference between zero-based budgeting and traditional budgeting?

Traditional, or incremental, budgeting starts from last year's budget and adjusts it by a percentage. Zero-based budgeting starts from zero and requires every activity to be justified again, so nothing is funded just because it was funded before.

Is a zero-based budget the same thing in personal finance?

Not quite. In personal finance, a zero-based budget means assigning every dollar of income to spending, saving or debt repayment until income minus allocations equals zero. The business method is about justifying each expense, not about allocating all income.

Is zero-based budgeting worth the effort?

It tends to pay off when costs have grown without review, after a merger or during a cost reduction program. For stable organizations, a periodic or partial zero-based review is often enough and costs far less than rebuilding the entire budget every year.

Let’s make AP
work for you.